Should I Choose a Standalone Shower or a Tub-Shower Combo?

Renovating your bathroom is one of the most impactful ways to enhance your home’s comfort, functionality, and value. One of the biggest decisions you’ll face is whether to install a standalone shower or a tub-shower combo. This choice isn’t just about aesthetics—it affects your daily routine, accessibility, future resale value, and even your budget. In this comprehensive guide, you’ll find everything you need to make an informed decision, including expert insights, design tips, and practical considerations for every type of homeowner.

Understanding Your Needs: The Foundation of a Smart Choice

Before diving into the pros and cons of each option, start by assessing your household’s needs and lifestyle. Are you remodeling a master bath, a family bathroom, or a guest suite? Do you have young children or plan to age in place? Is resale value a top priority, or are you designing your forever home?

For example, families with small children often prefer a tub for bath time, while busy professionals might value the convenience and accessibility of a standalone shower. If you’re planning to sell your home in the next few years, you’ll want to consider what local buyers are looking for—buyers in New York, NY (10001) may have different expectations than those in Dallas, TX (75201) or Los Angeles, CA (90001).

If you’re unsure which option fits your lifestyle, get a free, personalized bathroom consultation and quote at Repairmen.com or call 833-864-6908 to discuss your needs with an expert.

The Standalone Shower: Modern, Accessible, and Space-Saving

Pros of a Standalone Shower

Standalone showers are a hallmark of modern bathroom design. They offer a sleek, open look and can make even a small space feel larger. Frameless glass enclosures, curbless entries, and rainfall showerheads are just a few features that add both luxury and practicality.

Accessibility is a major advantage. For those with mobility challenges or who plan to age in place, a walk-in shower with a low or no threshold is much safer than stepping over a tub wall. Showers can be equipped with grab bars, built-in benches, and handheld showerheads for added comfort and safety.

Space efficiency is another benefit. In tight bathrooms, a corner or alcove shower can free up valuable floor space for storage or a larger vanity. Custom tile work and niche shelving allow you to tailor the design to your taste and needs.

Cons of a Standalone Shower

The main drawback is the lack of a tub, which can be a dealbreaker for families with young children or for those who enjoy soaking baths. In some real estate markets, not having at least one tub in the home can lower resale value.

Cost can also be a factor. While basic prefabricated shower units are affordable, custom tile showers with glass enclosures can be more expensive than tub-shower combos.

For a detailed cost comparison and design ideas, request a free, no-obligation quote at Repairmen.com or call 833-864-6908.

The Tub-Shower Combo: Versatility and Family-Friendly Function

Pros of a Tub-Shower Combo

A tub-shower combo is the most versatile option, offering the best of both worlds. You can enjoy quick showers on busy mornings and relaxing baths when you need to unwind. For families with children, a bathtub is almost essential for bath time.

Resale value is often higher in homes with at least one tub. Many real estate agents recommend keeping a tub in the main or secondary bathroom, especially in suburban or family-oriented neighborhoods like Orlando, FL (32801) or Chicago, IL (60601).

Cost-effectiveness is another advantage. Tub-shower combos are generally less expensive to install than custom standalone showers, especially if you choose a prefabricated unit. They’re also easier to retrofit into existing spaces.

Cons of a Tub-Shower Combo

The biggest downside is accessibility. Stepping over a tub wall can be difficult for seniors or those with mobility issues. The design can also feel dated or less luxurious compared to a modern walk-in shower. Cleaning can be more challenging as well, especially around the tub’s edges and shower curtain.

If you need help deciding which option is best for your family or property, speak with a bathroom renovation expert at Repairmen.com or call 833-864-6908.

Lifestyle Considerations: Who Uses the Bathroom?

Families with Young Children

A tub is almost always a must-have for families with babies or toddlers. Bathing small children is much easier (and safer) in a tub than a shower. If your home has only one bathroom, a tub-shower combo is usually the best choice.

Empty Nesters and Seniors

If you’re planning to age in place, a walk-in shower with grab bars and a bench is safer and more accessible. Consider replacing a tub with a curbless shower to future-proof your bathroom.

Young Professionals and Couples

For those who rarely take baths, a standalone shower maximizes space and style. However, if you plan to sell in the near future, consider whether potential buyers in your area expect a tub.

Guest Bathrooms

If you have multiple bathrooms, you might keep a tub in the main bath but opt for a standalone shower in the guest suite for a modern, hotel-like feel.

For advice tailored to your household’s needs, get a free bathroom assessment at Repairmen.com or call 833-864-6908.

Resale Value: What Do Buyers Want?

Real estate trends vary by region, but most experts agree that having at least one bathtub in the home is important for resale value. In family-friendly neighborhoods, buyers often look for a tub in the main or secondary bathroom. In urban condos or luxury homes, a large walk-in shower may be more desirable.

• Urban Markets (e.g., New York, NY 10001): Space is at a premium, and buyers may prioritize a luxurious shower over a tub, especially in master suites.

• Suburban Markets (e.g., Dallas, TX 75201): Families expect at least one tub, but may prefer a separate shower in the master bath.

• Vacation Homes: Spa-like showers are a selling point, but a tub is still valued for versatility.

If you’re remodeling with resale in mind, ask for a market analysis and recommendations from the experts at Repairmen.com or call 833-864-6908.

Accessibility and Aging in Place

As more homeowners plan to age in place, accessibility is a top concern. Walk-in showers with no threshold, slip-resistant tile, grab bars, and built-in benches make bathing safer and more comfortable for people of all ages and abilities.

If you or a family member has mobility challenges, a standalone shower is almost always the better choice. Tub-shower combos can be retrofitted with grab bars and non-slip mats, but they’re never as accessible as a curbless shower.

For an accessibility assessment and design ideas, schedule a free consultation at Repairmen.com or call 833-864-6908.

Design and Aesthetic Considerations

Standalone Shower Design Trends

• Frameless glass enclosures for a sleek, open look

• Custom tile work, including mosaics and accent walls

• Rainfall and multi-function showerheads

• Built-in niches and benches

• Curbless or low-threshold entries

• LED lighting and steam features

Tub-Shower Combo Design Trends

• Deep soaking tubs with integrated shower fixtures

• Sliding glass doors or modern shower curtains

• Tile surrounds for a custom look

• Niche shelving for bath products

• Compact tubs for small spaces

Both options can be customized to fit your style, whether you prefer modern minimalism, classic elegance, or rustic charm. For help designing your dream bathroom, request a free design consultation at Repairmen.com or call 833-864-6908.

Space and Layout: Making the Most of Your Bathroom

The size and layout of your bathroom may influence your decision. In small bathrooms, a standalone shower can free up space for storage or a larger vanity. In larger bathrooms, you might have room for both a separate tub and shower, creating a luxurious, spa-like retreat.

If you’re working with a compact bathroom, consider a corner shower or a tub-shower combo with a glass door to maximize visual space. For larger master suites, a freestanding tub paired with a walk-in shower offers the ultimate in comfort and style.

For a layout assessment and space-saving ideas, get a free quote from a bathroom remodel specialist at Repairmen.com or call 833-864-6908.

Cost Comparison: Standalone Shower vs. Tub-Shower Combo

Standalone Shower Costs

• Prefabricated shower stall: $1,000–$3,000 (including installation)

• Custom tile shower: $4,000–$10,000+

• Glass enclosure: $1,000–$3,000 extra

• Accessibility features: $500–$2,000

Tub-Shower Combo Costs

• Prefabricated tub-shower unit: $800–$2,500 (including installation)

• Custom tub-shower combo: $3,000–$6,000+

• Tile surround: $1,000–$3,000 extra

Costs vary by region, materials, and labor rates. For example, a custom shower in San Francisco, CA (94109) may cost more than the same project in Orlando, FL (32801).

For a detailed, itemized quote based on your location and preferences, request your free estimate at Repairmen.com or call 833-864-6908.

Maintenance and Cleaning

Showers are generally easier to clean, especially with frameless glass and large-format tiles that minimize grout lines. Tub-shower combos may require more effort to keep the tub clean, especially around the edges and fixtures.

Consider finishes that resist water spots and soap scum, and opt for easy-to-clean materials like porcelain, glass, or acrylic.

For advice on low-maintenance bathroom materials, consult with a renovation expert at Repairmen.com or call 833-864-6908.

Environmental and Water Usage Considerations

Showers typically use less water than baths, especially if you install a low-flow showerhead. However, long showers can negate these savings. If sustainability is important to you, choose WaterSense-certified fixtures and consider a shower timer.

For eco-friendly bathroom remodeling options, get a free consultation at Repairmen.com or call 833-864-6908.

Regional Trends: What’s Popular in Your Area?

• New York, NY (10001): Space-saving showers are popular in apartments and condos, but luxury homes may feature both a tub and shower.

• Los Angeles, CA (90001): Spa-like showers with rainfall heads and steam features are trending, but families still value a tub in at least one bathroom.

• Chicago, IL (60601): Tub-shower combos remain common in family homes, but modern condos often feature walk-in showers.

• Dallas, TX (75201): Large master baths often include both a standalone shower and a soaking tub.

For insights on what’s trending in your zip code, request a local market analysis at Repairmen.com or call 833-864-6908.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

Is it OK to remove the only tub in my house?
If you plan to sell, most real estate experts recommend keeping at least one tub for resale value. If you’re in your forever home and never use the tub, a shower may make more sense.

Which is safer for seniors: a tub or a shower?
A walk-in shower with grab bars and a bench is much safer than a tub for seniors or anyone with mobility issues.

Can I have both a standalone shower and a tub?
If space and budget allow, having both is ideal for flexibility and resale value.

How much does it cost to convert a tub to a shower?
Conversions typically cost $3,000–$8,000, depending on materials and labor.

What’s easier to clean: a shower or a tub-shower combo?
Showers, especially with frameless glass and large tiles, are generally easier to clean.

Does a standalone shower use less water than a bath?
Yes, most showers use less water than filling a tub, especially with a low-flow showerhead.

How do I get a free quote for my bathroom remodel?
Visit Repairmen.com or call 833-864-6908 for a detailed, no-obligation estimate.

Choosing between a standalone shower and a tub-shower combo is a personal decision that depends on your lifestyle, family needs, home layout, and future plans. Both options have their advantages, and the best choice is the one that fits your daily routine, budget, and long-term goals.

Ready to take the next step?
Get your free, no-obligation bathroom remodel quote today at Repairmen.com or call 833-864-6908. Expert advice and trusted contractors are just a click or call away!